2014 -- John Kerry, the Secretary of State, contends that the Ukrainian
showdown is a confrontation between a 19th century world view and a 21st
century approach. My problem is that the United States is the one with
the 18th century world view.
We went in to Vietnam because South Vietnam asked for help and we wanted to stop the spread of communism. Ho Chi Minh said no - you can't come in to our country. After ten years of bombing, flame throwing, and Agent Orange by the United States Ho won. We went into Iraq for various reasons. President George W. Bush wanted to prove Papa Bush wrong when he wrote in A World Transformed, "we should not march into Baghdad turning the whole Arab world against us assigning young soldiers to fight in what would be an unwinnable urban guerrilla war." Cheney wanted the oil and I felt it was in pursuance of Clean Break: an Israel study that suggested Saddam be replaced with a Hashemite ruler favorable to Israel.
George H.W. Bush was right. Iraq is "an unwinnable urban guerilla
war". After we chased Osama Bin Laden into Pakistan, we made war
on Afghanistan for no reason. Afghanistan didn't have an Army, no threat
to our security and grateful to the United States. Congressman Charlie
Wilson told me that we beat the Russians because the Afghans don't like
foreigners and Russians were foreigners. Today, we are the foreigners
and the Afghans are having a hard time getting rid of us. In George Crile's
book, Charlie Wilson's War, the words Al Qaeda or Taliban never appear.
The warlords will still be in control.
three wars, we have learned 1.) that the military can't change the culture
of a country 2.) we can't go in to help a country unless we find somebody
to lead it that can be democratically elected. That's why we stay out
are finding President Obama "weak" and "nobody believes
in America's strength anymore". As Gideon Rachman writes in the Financial
Times (3/11/14), "The fact that Mr. Obama seems to have ruled out
a military response is proof, not that he is weak, but that he is sane."
Nobody believes in America's strength anymore because the "nobody" is mistakenly thinking of military power. With nuclear weaponry limited to defense of the homeland and globalization having Corporate America downfield, blocking to spread democracy, entities like the National Endowment for Democracy can get you into trouble. Google NED and you will find 66 entities have been working in the Ukraine for years. In the contest of Russia versus the European Union to have Ukraine join the Russian Eurasian Union or the European Union , both sides were backing "ne'er do well" leaders and both sides were financing the demonstrators and upheaval. When the Democratic elected government opted for Russia, our crowd couldn't wait for a democratic election so we overthrew the Democratic elected President of Ukraine. This forced Putin to protect Russian interest in Ukraine.
200 years, Ukraine has been a part of Russia. In 1954, Khrushchev gave
Crimea to Ukraine but Crimea has the important port of Sevastopol for
the Russian Navy. In winter, Russian Northern Ports are frozen over and
Sevastopol is the only outlet for Russia's Navy to the Mediterranean and
Atlantic. Now, the Wall Street Journal (3/13/14) headlines: "Obama,
Kerry Warn of Consequences as Crimea Vote Nears". We shouldn't be
warning anybody. We are the troublemakers. Thousands of miles from our
security, we're the ones with the "18th century view". We should
realize that after retreating to the 38th parallel in Korea, the United
States was sensitive to casualties. We should realize that we could have
taken Vietnam in two weeks instead of losing it in ten years because we
didn't go above Hanoi for fear that China would come in.
Ukraine is a good lesson for us. It reminds us that the strength of the United States is in its democracy and economy. The lead for our foreign policy and "spreading democracy" is not the military but our Good Neighbor Policy. Apparently China has already learned this lesson. In 1989, at Tiananmen Square, the U.S. obtained a Resolution at the U.N. to investigate human rights in China. China went to its economic friends in Africa and the Pacific and there's never been a hearing on the Resolution.
seized China's ship captain, China withheld rare earth supplies from Japan
and Japan promptly and quietly returned the ship captain. By this time
next year, China will have the largest economy in the world and within
five years, China will have as strong a military as the United States.
China's controlled capitalism is working. Its large Army not only protects
China but protects the Central Committee which is determined to keep China
together as a nation. To practice our democracy, China would come apart.
Rather than using our Defense Budget in diplomacy, we need to use a copy
of Dale Carnegie's: How to Win Friends and Influence People.
The Good Neighbor Policy depends on our economy which is being neglected. The United States is not competing in globalization - it's draining its economy. Corporate America continues to offshore its research, technology, production and jobs and the President and Congress fail to make it attractive for Corporate America to invest in America.
We've got to get rid of the Corporate Tax that's not rebated on exports and adopt a VAT that is rebated. Replacing the 35% Corporate Tax with a 7% VAT produces billions to pay down the debt, refunds Social Security and releases $2 trillion in offshore profits for Corporate America to repatriate tax free and create millions of jobs. Bush and Obama did not enforce the Defense Production Act of 1950. As a result, we were begging Russia for helicopters for Afghanistan and had to bail out General Motors and Detroit. The United States was built on Protectionism- The Tariff Act of 1787.
to be enforcing laws against China and Japan's closed markets and predatory
practices. But the President and Congress get the contributions from Wall
Street, the big banks and Corporate America to do nothing and the President
and Congress do nothing.
Senator Hollings of South Carolina served 38 years in the United States Senate, and for many years was Chairman of the Commerce, Space, Science & Transportation Committee. He is the author of Making Government Work (University of South Carolina Press, 2008).
© 2014, Ernest F. Hollings. All rights reserved. Contact us for republication permission.
About Fritz Hollings
Receive commentary via The Huffington Post
The Hollings legacy
Read the new book